Alright, so I was on Facebook last night and one of my friends commented on this article about mothers who left their kids in the car, so I decided to read it. This is kind of unusual for me because, well, I’m lazy and the article was fairly long. haha. Now, go read this article because if you read the rest of my post, you’re not going to get it and/or think I’m a horrible person/mother. I’ll wait….
So I read it, and afterwards, I read the comments because when something serious/controversial is written, the comments are usually a good read.
As I was reading these comments, it baffled me that the majority of them were completely ridiculous and, honestly, mean towards these mothers. These aren’t women who were being neglectful. They weren’t thinking, “I’m going to leave my child in a hot car because I’m too lazy to get them out.” They were thinking, “I have to get toilet paper. My child is asleep. It’s not hot out and it’s overcast. I’ll be gone 10 minutes tops.” They locked the door and went into the store only to come out and find people standing at their car. This isn’t the problem that I see. Someone watching out for kids is what the article was about. The whole “it takes a village” mentality. The problem was the attitude of these people. They weren’t helping for the sake of the child. They were doing it because they felt the mom wasn’t being a good parent, which is different even if you don’t think it is. Let me explain my thinking.
Someone who was worried about the child in a case such as this would first make sure the child is okay. Peek in, tap on the glass. Especially if you saw the parent walk away. While I don’t agree with leaving a child in a car like this and would never do it, other parents might disagree. The circumstances of these children were not dire. For crying out loud, one of the mothers left her two children in the car, one of which was eight! She had an iPad and could text her mother who was in the store. This situation in particular is ridiculous. If I were that child and saw a bunch of strangers outside the car staring at me, I would’ve texted my mother and said there were creepy people looking at me, wouldn’t you? Those people could’ve easily asked the child if she and her sibling were okay. The other two situations, maybe they couldn’t. I bet if any of those people had waited and said in kindness and out of concern, “I was just making sure someone was coming back quickly. Did you know it can dangerous to leave a child in a car like this?” Why not talk to a parent like they are human beings rather than assuming they are horrible, no good parents who don’t care about their children. 9 times out of 10, I would guess they would be responsive to your question if you said it in a kind and concerned manner rather than accusing them. One lady commented that she had her own children to get home to and didn’t want to put herself in danger. Uh, seriously? If you’re that worried about the child to call 911, you can’t wait outside the car while they arrive and risk the mother talking to you? I’m sorry, I have a hard time believing that. If I were that worried about the child, I’d smash the window to get them out.
I did some research and found that it’s 12% of child deaths were circumstances like this…where the parent willingly left the child in the car. While that is really sad, that also means that almost 90% percent of deaths from being left in a car weren’t from parents willingly doing it. These statistics came from over 10 years of data collected. So the chance that the circumstances are serious enough to call the authorities is not very good.
Now, the reason I’m so frustrated with this is not because I don’t think these people were actually trying to help. I’m frustrated because I don’t think these people were thinking it through. If you know that the parent did it willingly, i.e. you saw them peek in the window to make sure they were okay before walking away, then chances are, they are coming back quickly. Don’t you think that the child deserves you to wait before you turn their would upside down? What’s going to happen when the parent comes back less than 10 minutes later and you’ve called the police for nothing? That mom is still going to be arrested, and that little girl or boy is going to have to watch. One of the moms had to miss her daughters first day of school because of the court date, that was most definitely avoidable if someone had decided to check on the kid(s) first and wait a few moments. These peoples lives were turned upside down.
Again, I don’t agree with what these women did. Leaving your car completely unattended with children in it is risky, but is it necessarily child endangerment or neglect?
I have a friend who was threatened for putting her kids in their carseats and walking a cart to the cart return in the parking lot. She closed the doors and locked the car. Walked, maybe, 30 feet tops, and walked back. Is that really something that the authorities need to be involved in? Next time you return a Redbox, do you need to take all 3 kids out, the stroller (so you can put the baby down and maybe look for a new movie) and then go to the machine which is, literally, right in front of the car just so you don’t get the cops called on you? You better start, because our world is quickly becoming a “I know better” world and less of a “Oh, I get that” world. We are parenting out fear of being judged rather than parenting our individual children. What works for one parent might not work for another, and that’s okay. Do we really need to call the police when it’s something we don’t agree with?